Take-out Tuesday, Sugar Cookie Birthday Pie

NG, my son-in-law, is the nicest guy you will ever meet


He also has a major sweet tooth


So for his birthday last week, I made him a giant sugar cookie pie


And topped it with chopped peanut butter cups


I was trying to make up for the fact that for Christmas we gave CC a storage bench and Charlie Brown a play table, but they both had to be put together, and the bench was missing instructions which made it extra fun…


Then a Home Depot gift card for his birthday, which I’m sure will be used for household projects…DD had him painting the hallway the day after Christmas!


This guy deserved a cookie!


This recipe is adapted from Betty Crocker, she said to mix it with a spoon,


I’m sorry Betty, that’s way too much work so I opted for a hand mixer, but next time it will go straight into the food processor or stand mixer


Mix sprinkles into the dough and pat in into a big cookie in a springform pan or a pie plate


I used a springform pan for ease of removal


Let cookie cool completely before icing and garnishing


Sugar Cookie Birthday Pie

Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 35 minutes
Decorating time 10 minutes
Course Dessert
Cuisine American
Servings 10


  • round cake pan


Cookie Pie

  • 1 large pouch 1 lb. 5 oz, Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Mix
  • 1/2 cup butter softened and cut into cubes
  • 1 egg
  • multi-colored sprinkles optional


  • 1 1/2 cups powdered sugar
  • 3 T butter softened
  • 3-4 T milk
  • 1 T almond emulsion or almond or vanilla extract
  • sprinkles chopped peanut butter cups or candy of choice


  • Spray the bottom of a springform pan or glass pie dish with cooking spray.
  • Mix cookie mix, butter and egg in mixer or with a beater until a soft dough forms.
  • Stir in sprinkles if desired.
  • Put dough in baking pan and pat into a level layer.
  • Bake at 325 for about 35 minutes, checking near the end of baking time. Cookie is done when set in the middle and edges begin to brown.
  • Cool completely before icing


  • Beat sugar, butter, extract, and milk until desired consistency.Β 
  • If icing is too thin add more sugar, if it's too thick add more milk
  • Spread icing evenly over top of cookie and sprinkle with desired toppings
Keyword sprinkles, sugar cookie birthday pie, sugar cookie cake, sugar cookie pizza, sugar cookies

He gave it rave reviews!


You can use any kind of cookie dough, sprinkles, or icing flavor and toppings you like


Cut it in very small wedges or pieces because it’s obviously very rich!

🍭   πŸŽ‚   🍰   🍭   πŸŽ‚   🍰

I will be joining these fabulous parties and blogs:

Celebrate and DecorateRustic and Refined,

Between Naps on the Porch, Coastal Charm, Cooking and Crafting with J&JThe Scoop,   A Stroll Thru Life 

Tickle My TastebudsFull Plate Thursday

 Your Inspired Design   Share it One More Time








14 Responses to “Take-out Tuesday, Sugar Cookie Birthday Pie”
  1. Wow! That’s a super original birthday gift! Looks good too

  2. Mary says:

    He does deserve a cookie or two Jenna! I told my hubby when he retires he needs to go into the “some assembly required” business since he’s everyone’s Mr. Fix It πŸ™‚

    P. S. Sending my condolences your way this morning after that nail biting game last night.

  3. Jodi says:

    That’s some MAJOR SWEET stuff! πŸ™‚ But he sure deserved it! LOL!

  4. Stacey says:

    That looks amazing!! What a great idea to make it at home. πŸ™‚

  5. That’s a great idea! And it look delish, too! (Nice mom, paybacks for the construction!)

  6. Jenna, he definitely deserved a giant cookie and it looks delicious. I also have a sweet tooth and got a bit carried away over the holidays! It was a tough game and I do congratulate Clemson and Dabo! RTR

  7. Cecilia says:

    What a great idea! And the photos look awesome. Thanks for sharing.

  8. Everything’s better with sprinkles:@)

  9. lulu says:

    What a nice compliment for your son-in-law. I bet he thinks he got a pretty good deal, too! I’m betting the kids didn’t mind indulging in his sweet either.

  10. Your cookie looks great and sure SIL enjoyed it.
    I’m disappointed about the game 😒 also.

Leave a Reply to itsabakerslifeCancel reply

%d bloggers like this: